The Good Life > Healthy Food > Talking Turkey: Conventional Turkey or Heritage Turkey

Talking Turkey: Conventional Turkey or Heritage Turkey

Conventional Turkey or Heritage Turkey
email Print

What is a Heritage Turkey?

Heritage turkeys are an old-fashioned breed, but their popularity has shown a recent resurgence. Heritage turkeys are hard-to-find breeds such as Narragansett, Standard Bronze, Blue Slate and Bourbon Reds. They are similar to what the Pilgrims themselves enjoyed during holiday times.

These breeds have smaller breasts, darker leg meat and a truer, gamier "turkey" flavor than the factory-farm raised turkeys. Heritage birds are also raised for longer periods than the conventional birds. These breeds have a slaughter age of 26 to 28 weeks, while the conventional bird is ready for slaughter in 14-18 weeks. Heritage birds are also raised in smaller flocks and are generally given access to fresh air, sunshine, and pasture, making them more humanely raised than their factory-farm raised counterpart. This extra grow time and freedom allows for sturdier and more flavorful meat; two things very important to the outcome of your holiday meal.

Conventional Turkey

Conventional turkeys, or factory farmed turkeys, are a breed known to farmers as the Broad Breasted White Turkey. This breed was selectively bred by USDA scientists over the past five decades with the primary focus being on maximum breast meat growth and minimum grow times.

While this result answers to the average American's demand—maximum white meat for rock-bottom costs—the one truly paying the price are the genetically modified birds raised under these difficult conditions. The cost to the birds includes cramped, unsanitary growing spaces with little to no fresh air or daylight, and jam-packed with disproportioned birds that are too meaty in the chest area to fly or reproduce.

Heritage Turkeys are Raised Humanely

If the differences between the way heritage birds are raised relative to conventional birds isn't enough to help you decide which turkey you prefer, the thought of all the additives and preservatives added to conventional turkeys just might.

Many store-bought conventional turkeys are generally injected with salt, water and other preservatives during processing to assist with the extended shelf life and to make sure that they make it thousands of miles from the factory to your home (which could take days, if not longer) before going bad. Since heritage turkeys are not mass produced, the heritage breed turkeys are not injected with preservatives, which allow you to enjoy one hundred percent of the turkey’s true flavor.

Finding Your Heritage Turkey

While conventional turkeys are found in abundance in every supermarket in the United States, heritage breed turkeys can be a little more work to find, but the effort is worth it. Heritage turkeys can generally be found at local specialty farms, organic markets and Amish or Mennonite farms if you are lucky enough to have some in your area at a local farm. The internet is an invaluable resource to finding your holiday bird. Websites such as and provide helpful information for families interested in farms currently raising heritage turkeys. Many turkey farms offer shipping throughout the United States.

There is a price difference between the conventional and heritage turkey, but the reasons for the extra costs are justified, particularly once you spend a little time with the farmers to learn how exactly they raised a happy, healthy heritage turkey.

Taste is not the only factor to consider for the optimal experience. If you, like many others, are trying to be more mindful of the moral and environmental impact of your food choices, then Thanksgiving dinner is the perfect start. If you are willing to pay more for a higher quality bird, the heritage breed provides you with the opportunity to support a local farm and enjoy your meal knowing the turkey got to enjoy its entire life like a true turkey should—without confinement and with all the fresh air it can breathe. Take the plunge for the holiday meal this year! You will never look at a conventional supermarket turkey the same way again.

Find a Turkey from Your Local Farm

Still Can’t Decide What To Buy? Consult the Turkey Buying Guide

Laura Holt, for Agrilicious!

To place comments please Log in or Create an Account.
JanetDee, Port Townsend WA
I just love Heritage turkeys. They are truly personable and more able to care for themselves in the pasture. The hens can make good permanent farm critters.
1/29/2015 8:48:00 AM
login to report
Reeves Ranch Farms has been a co-op Heritage Turkey producer for years. Please visit our Facebook page to find out more information or to place a deposit for your next heritage turkey!
12/20/2014 10:54:00 PM
login to report
I just got the message Beth! Apologies - I've been on the East Coast. I'll follow up with you when I'm back in the office mid-week!
11/25/2014 10:54:00 AM
login to report
beth57, Dayton OH
Hey Laura, I sent you a message about utilizing this article on my blog, Just want to make sure you get the message :) Beth
11/19/2014 9:22:00 AM
login to report
Thanks for your feeback! It's important to us that while we spread awareness about local food and farms that our information is as robust as possible. We work to not speak in "absolutes" - I agree with your point that both BB breeds can be raised humanely, free range, organic and natural. I will update our article to be more specific conventional turkey. By the way - congratulations to the Long Shadow Farm on selling out your turkey inventory! Another banner year. We love local farm raised turkey - happy, healthy birds!
11/18/2014 8:40:00 PM
login to report
As a turkey farmer, there are a few things in the article that aren't accurate. Yes - commercially raised turkeys are the Broad-Breasted White turkey. However, there are also Broad-Breasted Bronze turkeys, and both BB breeds can be raised humanely, free range, organic and natural. Don't make the assumption that all Broad-Breasted breeds are white, and all are raised in factory settings. They are HYBRIDS, they are NOT genetically modified. There is a difference! Also, the birds closest to what the pilgrims ate are wild strains of turkeys, which can also be raised on farms, but not usually.
11/13/2014 3:36:00 PM
login to report
Did You Know?
Like other birds and mammals, chickens experience REM sleep, which is associated with dreaming.